by Dennis Winge

Saraswati, the Hindu goddess of knowledge, music, art, wisdom, and learning
Saraswati, the Hindu goddess of knowledge, music, art, wisdom, and learning

Are your ears craving some new exotic-sounding harmonies?  Are you stuck writing the same old types of tunes and need some fresh material to inspire you?  Have you heard unusual modes but not sure how to use them in tunes?

This article will show you how to take an unusual scale or mode and make a tune out of it.  By "unusual" I mean one that is apart from the usual Major Scale and its modes, Melodic Minor and its modes, Diminished, Whole Tone, Harmonic Minor etc.  You may have heard a cool-sounding scale in Mediterranean or Indian music, for example, but its potential for use in your everyday playing may not be immediately apparent.

I am certainly no expert on Ragas or Indian classical music, I am just a jazz guitarist who discovered a way to take some of the "thaats" from India (the equivalent of a Western scale or mode).  I simply take the notes and harmonize them like we do with Western scales.  Of course in Indian music there is no real "harmony."  The notes are played against a drone, and it is very fun to do this on guitar.  So before we get into harmonizing, let's explore the thaats themselves and also discuss the possibilities of playing melodically over a drone.

I.  The 4 Thaats that are unusual to Western ears

There are 10 basic thaats, and we are not concerned here with the ones that have direct Western equivalents (like, for example, Bilawal, which is the same as the Ionian mode).  We are going to list the ones that have no Western equivalents (except for "Bhairav" which is also known as "Double Harmonic.")

They are:

Thaat Intervals Standard Notation in "C"

Bhairav

1  b2  3  4  5  b6  7  8

Puravi

1  b2  3  #4  5  b6  7  8

Marva

1  b2  3  #4  5  6  7  8

Todi

1  b2  b3  #4  5  b6  7  8

II.  The Joy of Modal Playing

If you're like me you might think at first that it's a bit too "static" to just play modally with a set of 7 notes over a drone.  But the advantages of just taking one of these scales and working with it are many:

A.  New sounds. You're familiarizing your ear with the character of the scale, and exploring its emotional potential.

B.  Intervallic training.  Can you really play it for 5 minutes with no mistakes?  I'll bet at least once your fingers will do a pattern they know so well and throw in an interval outside the mode.  It's great practice to think only in intervals rather than rely on your ear or on finger patterns.

C.  Fretboard theory.  Can you play the scale in any position?  Can you do the scale in 2 octaves using 7 different fingerings?  Similar to the "interval" training described above, doing scales like this could shed light on some weaker areas in your fretboard knowledge.

D.  Chromaticism.  Can you access the other 5 notes that aren't in the mode and still preserve the original character of the mode?  It's great fun and a good challenge.

So, have fun with playing these scales at different tempos and time signatures and in different keys.

III.  Harmonizing the Scales

Here is where East meets West.  We take each of the 7 notes and harmonize them out to 7th chords.  The result looks like this: 

Bhairav

Imaj7   bIImaj7   IIIm6   IVm(maj7)  V7b5  bVImaj7#5  bII7/VII 

Puravi

Imaj7   bIImaj7sus4   IIIm6   bVI7#5/#IV  Vmaj7b5  bVImaj7#5  bII7sus4/VII 

Marva

Imaj7   bIImaj7#5sus4   IIIm6   #IVm7b5  Vmaj7b5  VIm7  #IVm/VII

Todi

Im(maj7)   bIImaj7sus4   bIII7#5   bVI7/#IV  Vmaj7b5  bVImaj7  bII7sus4/VII

If you have any trouble understanding the above, just do it for yourself and you'll see.  For example, the 1, 3, 5, and 7 of Bhairav in the key of C is c, e, g, and b which of course is C major 7.  The chord built off the 3rd degree of that scale, again for example, is e, g, b and db which is Em6. 

Once you harmonize the scale, play around with the chords and see what might sound like a pleasant "progression."  I put the word progression in quotes because the chords aren't really taking you anywhere because it's all modal, but certain combinations of chords may better give you the feeling of movement moreso than others.

To illustrate what I mean, let's take a random mode and a random key for one of the above thaats.  I choose the 3rd mode of Todi and the key of C#.  

The Todi scale in C#:  c# - d - e - g - g# - a - c - c#

Third Mode of C# Todi    e - g - g# - a - c - c# - d - e

Harmonized Scale of Third Mode:  E7+5   A/G   Abmaj7b5   Amaj7  C69   Dmaj7sus4

So I take these chords and start playing around with them and simply see where my ear takes me.  My ear can relate to the sound of the C69 and also the very last melody note "a" over an E7+5 sounds like an early resolution so it felt good to use it at the end.   Here's what it looks like:

Here is an audio example:

Notice also that I stuck very closely to the mode at hand while improvising.  I didn't do anything fancy and I didn't even go above or below one octave and it still sounded relatively interesting to my ear.

This may not be an award-winning song but at least it opens you up to possibilities.  I used this concept on "Puravi Sketch" on my new album One Small Step (releases February 2019) and I'd love to hear yours as well. :)  Good luck and have fun.


About the author: Dennis Winge is a professional guitarist living in the Finger Lakes area of New York State who has a passion for vegan food and bhakti yoga. He has 4 instrumental albums out and performs and teaches in the Finger Lakes area of New York State.

Add your comment   There are 0 comments on this article so far

Comment on this article

Name
Email address
solve the following equation: 4 - 1 =


1939 Epiphone deluxe archtop acoustic guitar

SUNNYVALE, CALIFORNIA, 94085, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

$5825

Beautiful, super light weight, great sounding example of classic era Epiphones, Spruce top, Maple sides, back and neck. Was cased for years and suffered a disintegrating pickguard that affected body binding (outer ply replaced ), parts of neck binding (needs attention), part of lower F-hole binding replaced. Nice repro pickguard ,unbroken Frequensater tailpiece . 25 1 / 2" scale. Original case, showing effects of pickguard rot, replaced handle (have remnants of original, if desired). Great ... more

Kay Speed Demon Airline Vintage 1960's Truetone archtop electric Guitar Rare Red

BUFFALO, NEW YORK, 14225, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

$799

Vintage Red Speed Demon. 3 Pick-up. This is a Great Guitar. Nice clean instrument . all original. Plays nice . Has some play wear check pics ... more

Cont Heirloom Archtop Jazz Guitar - Solid Spruce Top, Solid Maple Back / Sides

IDAHO FALLS, IDAHO, 83404, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

$1849

Webster's Dictionary defines an heirloom as: "a valuable object that is owned by a family for many years and passed from one generation to another " Following the worldwide acceptance and success of the first generation of Conti Guitars, we are extremely proud to introduce the new generation of Conti Guitars, now appropriately named the Heirloom Edition, as we believe this instrument will remain with your family for a lifetime. The Heirloom features a Solid Spruce Top with Solid Maple Sides and ... more

Cont Heirloom Archtop Jazz Guitar - Solid Spruce Top, Solid Maple Back / Sides

IDAHO FALLS, IDAHO, 83404, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

$1849

Webster's Dictionary defines an heirloom as: "a valuable object that is owned by a family for many years and passed from one generation to another " Following the worldwide acceptance and success of the first generation of Conti Guitars, we are extremely proud to introduce the new generation of Conti Guitars, now appropriately named the Heirloom Edition, as we believe this instrument will remain with your family for a lifetime. The Heirloom features a Solid Spruce Top with Solid Maple Sides and ... more

Cont Heirloom Archtop Jazz Guitar - Solid Spruce Top, Solid Maple Back / Sides

IDAHO FALLS, IDAHO, 83404, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

$1849

Webster's Dictionary defines an heirloom as: "a valuable object that is owned by a family for many years and passed from one generation to another " Following the worldwide acceptance and success of the first generation of Conti Guitars, we are extremely proud to introduce the new generation of Conti Guitars, now appropriately named the Heirloom Edition, as we believe this instrument will remain with your family for a lifetime. The Heirloom features a Solid Spruce Top with Solid Maple Sides and ... more

Cont Heirloom Archtop Jazz Guitar - Solid Spruce Top, Solid Maple Back / Sides

IDAHO FALLS, IDAHO, 83404, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

$1849

Webster's Dictionary defines an heirloom as: "a valuable object that is owned by a family for many years and passed from one generation to another " Following the worldwide acceptance and success of the first generation of Conti Guitars, we are extremely proud to introduce the new generation of Conti Guitars, now appropriately named the Heirloom Edition, as we believe this instrument will remain with your family for a lifetime. The Heirloom features a Solid Spruce Top with Solid Maple Sides and ... more

Find more jazz guitars for sale at jazzguitarsforsale.com